
No doubt about it I’m biased but its great to see James Cleverly so emphatically chosen to be Conservative candidate for London Mayor.
I’m pleased for my friend, and former boss, but already – and it make me happy to see – Festus and Sara are being great team players and showing real class, in not winning. There’s got to be a decent role for both in the campaign should they want it.
I think this is winnable, and it’s not just friendship that makes me say that.
In the entire time I’ve known him, including the two years I worked side by side with him, I’ve never actually seen James Cleverly lose his temper. He can but I’ve never seen it, and I’ve spent more time with him than most and at some pretty difficult times too.
He sometimes goes quiet, and I can tell he’s annoyed, or he’ll draw you aside and say “I’m not saying I am grumpy about this, but there’s every chance I might get grumpy if X, Y or Z isn’t dealt with”. Those were the two signals we’d pick up as his SpAds that there was some work needed to be done to oil the wheels or unlock obstacles or just solve the problem with his backing.
He’d always point out to us that nobody – other Spads, ministers, cabinet colleagues and senior officials – should mistake politeness for weakness, and actually I came to see it as one of his big strengths – among many that he doesn’t get enough credit for.
It became a powerful driver of work that we were never angry but perhaps disappointed, that you needed to take people with you and say “look this is the decision, and now we have to make it work, so lets just stay focussed on that. He’d buy his lunch in the departmental canteens, chat with anyone whatever their job, and was one of the most popular Secretary of States in the three departments he worked in. Four as a minister.
Furthermore the fact that he was clear minded and could explain to officials how he made decisions (the real business of a Secretary of State is to say yes, or no and if no, why no) helped take them in the same direction. I’ve seen him go into a meeting where he knows the outcome they want and simply, politely and directly explain not only that that isn’t the result they are looking for but get them to appreciate accept and even support the result he wanted. It was always quite something to watch.
Yes, I’m well aware, due to his name that some opponents like to portray him as no big thinker, but I can attest that nobody who has dealings with him says that, and most that do just wanted the jobs he had. It’s partly a by-product of the personality he is that he is easy to talk to, almost always cheerful, loyal to whoever has shown him kindness, loyalty and helped him along the way. People don’t realise it masks a fiercely practical mind that knows how to get things done.
He likes to crack jokes, tell anecdotes (heavens sake don’t get him talking about artillery or you will never get away – entertaining though he can make it) and even sing! He once exited the Home Secretary’s office and started singing and busting a few moves – somehow the slightly startled civil servants smiled rather than scoffed, they knew by then he doesn’t take himself too seriously in order to get serious stuff done.
The genial nature of the man is the extra element he’ll need to win in London. I don’t think Sadiq Khan, if he decides to run again, is nearly as secure in his chances of victory as he thinks.
What is true is, Cleverly is a Conservative to his finger tips and I don’t think the slightly odd media framing of the latter stages of the 2024 leadership contest as “Tom and James on the left and Rob and Kemi on the right” was really true. Rob seems to have gone all ‘unionista’ anti-Thatcher in the last 24 hours. Tom Tugenhat can be as hawkish as you like, and it’s good to see him back on the frontlines, and judging from tuesday’s ConHome Shadow Cabinet league table Tory members think the same. James was a Brexiteer early on – even when warned it would end his career – he has had friends and allies in every wing of the party and his political heroes are Thatcher and Reagan – the latter probably more so.
You can see why.
Reagan in his heyday politically used his personal charm and bonhomie, and an artful self deprecation to win admiration from like minded supporters, and respect from political opponents. It can bind and galvanise a campaign. It can make it come alive, and frankly a mayoral contest has needed that.
I’m not rubbishing previous contenders it’s just Cleverly is probably the highest profile candidate the party has put forward since Boris, and Boris was just an MP at the time. The time Cleverly spent in the Home Office, the Foreign Office (he was there longer than just as Foreign Secretary) and a useful stint in the shadow housing, communities and local government brief will give him the gravitas to square up to Khan who’ll push all the “I have the experience” buttons he can muster. If he runs. If not, there is a big CV the Labour contender will have to match.
However, Cleverly can’t rely on just Conservative votes to win London, but he’ll need people who think they can vote for , personally, even if the party isn’t their first choice. As he himself has said, it will be hard, but having seen him campaign, and hold office, up close, I genuinely believe he can do it.
Sadiq? Ball’s now in your court. Serve or quit?