
Cllr David Rogers is the Deputy Leader of the Conservative Group on Cherwell District Council.
Last week, Angela Rayner granted planning permission for the former MOD Bicester Site A to accommodate up to 1,256 single adult male asylum seekers. This is wrong for the people of Piddington and wrong for the people who may be housed there.
It is wrong on so many levels, and says a great deal about the way this Government approaches decisions that have very real consequences for local communities.
She did so despite objections from Cherwell District Council, concerns raised by Oxfordshire County Council and considerable local opposition.
It is difficult to understand how such a decision can be justified when so many practical questions remain unanswered.
The Government chose to use the Urgent Crown Development procedure, meaning that the decision was taken by the Secretary of State. Cherwell District Council objected, as did others, raising questions about the suitability of the site and the lack of supporting information. What is particularly concerning is that the decision gives substantial weight to the national requirement for asylum accommodation, but relatively little weight to the impact on the local community.
In other words, the Government’s need to find somewhere to put people appears to have taken precedence over whether this is actually a sane place to put them.
Site A is a former military storage and distribution centre. It was never intended to accommodate a residential population of this size. The surrounding roads are rural, with limited pavements, poor lighting and inadequate pedestrian access. The B4011 is particularly concerning. The people housed there will not be detained. They’ll be free to come and go, which makes the question of safe access rather important.
The suggestion that high-visibility clothing and shuttle buses will somehow address the problem hardly inspires confidence.
Then there is the construction itself, with questions about contamination, asbestos, unexploded ordnance, drainage, wastewater treatment and fire safety.
These are not objections invented by local residents. They are matters raised through the planning process and which need proper answers.
And what about healthcare for both the existing population and those who might be housed at Site A?
We already know that local GP practices are struggling with capacity. The NHS has warned that nearby practices have no spare capacity, yet three Bicester surgeries have reportedly been told to prepare for around 400 additional patients each.
That is potentially another 1,200 patients being added to practices that are already full.
There has been no clear, publicly verified explanation of what additional resources will be made available.
The Home Office talks about healthcare facilities on site, but that does not explain how ongoing primary care, prescriptions, mental health services or referrals to hospital will be managed.
We have enough difficulty getting new GP premises delivered for housing developments that have been planned for years. Yet here we have the Government proposing to introduce more than a thousand additional people without demonstrating how their healthcare needs will be met.
That is hardly fair on existing patients, and it is certainly not fair on those who will be accommodated at Site A.
There are similar questions about security. The Home Office proposes CCTV, security staff and arrangements for residents to sign in and out. But this is not a detention centre, and those living there will be free to leave. Thames Valley’s Police and the Crime Commissioner has raised concerns about policing and the resources that may be needed. What additional provision will be made, and who will pay for it?
The Government cannot simply assume that existing local services will absorb whatever additional demands arise. We are told that moving asylum seekers out of hotels will save money. Perhaps it will. But where is the financial justification?
What will it cost to convert the site, operate it for ten years, provide security, transport, healthcare and policing, and deal with any necessary infrastructure improvements?
And how much of that cost will fall on local services rather than the Home Office?
There is a difference between saving money and simply moving expenditure from one public body to another and I would expect an assurance that the full cost will be covered by HM Gov rather than from our council tax.
What troubles me most about Angela Rayner’s decision is not simply that she has approved a controversial development. It is that the Government has chosen to proceed despite so many concerns about the practical consequences.
There is a familiar pattern here. Central government makes a decision to meet a national objective, while local authorities, public services and residents are left to deal with the implications.
The Home Office has yet to make its final decision on whether to open the site, but planning permission has now been granted.
Before anyone is moved into Site A, ministers should explain exactly how the outstanding issues will be addressed, what additional resources will be provided and who will be responsible if the arrangements prove inadequate.
Piddington is a small rural community. Its residents are entitled to expect that their concerns will be taken seriously. Equally, the people who may be housed at Site A merit a reasonable level of consideration.
Neither group benefits from a decision driven primarily by the need to find accommodation quickly yet this will not be a quick solution as infrastructure issues abound.
This is what makes this such a questionable decision. The Government has found somewhere it can put 1,256 people, jolly good, job done seems to be the thought process. What tosh, it’s a terrible outcome for all concerned and an example of the centralised decision making that Labour brings to any argument.
Rayner and the Home Office must now account for how those concerns have been addressed, what safeguards will be delivered and who will bear the costs.