
It is a message reminiscent of David Cameron, Theresa May and Boris Johnson before him. Like his predecessors, Burnham is trying to win better treatment from a technocratic Brussels machine — a tough job for Hamish Falconer, the ex-diplomat who once negotiated with the Taliban and is now European relations minister.
One person who was in a recent meeting with Falconer said: “I sat in a meeting with Hamish where he was saying, I’m pretty sure with geopolitics and my negotiating prowess, the EU will give us a special deal on the single market.” (A U.K. official said they did not recognize this characterization.) The same person said each administration had thought they could forge a better relationship with Brussels than the one that came before, and “I’m worried that Burnham is falling into that same trap.”
An official who worked on Brexit issues under Starmer added: “Politicians always unfortunately have a strong lack of realpolitik in this space. No matter what pathway the U.K. decides to take, the EU will get what it wants.”
Personality plays a part too. When Burnham met European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen on the same day as U.S. President Donald Trump at the U.N. General Assembly, the stark difference in character did not go unnoticed. While British officials respect Von der Leyen’s precise, calm style, Trump’s approach was far more like Burnham’s — conversational, anecdotal and gliding over the hard policy details.
After Burnham’s September speech, confused officials from EU member countries tried to decode his pledge to lay out options “around” the EU-U.K. summit. Some complained privately that the PM should’ve been clearer that the summit was about technical talks that began under Starmer, and talks about the world beyond that could only begin afterwards.
Sandro Gozi, an MEP for French President Emmanuel Macron’s Renaissance party, said he agreed with Burnham that “Brexit has been a disaster,” but added: “I hope that [he] will be bolder and more specific.”