Last year, I invited a group called Justice for Innocent Men Scotland (JIMS) to speak to my fourth-year criminology class.
I had come across this grassroots group, made up largely of women whose partners or sons had been convicted of rape, on Facebook. What impressed me was that the group didn’t talk about individual cases. Rather, they were campaigning about the lack of fair trials in rape cases — the very subject I was researching at the time.
People are often sceptical about wives or mothers claiming innocence for their imprisoned loved ones. This may seem harsh, but it is also understandable. But JIMS were not doing this directly. What they were identifying was the growing use of rape shield legislation, policies, and practices within the criminal justice system, most noticeably the restriction of evidence that was taking place in rape trials.
Again, this was exactly what I was looking into. It was also something that Thomas Ross KC was speaking out about at the time.
Ross is one of the very few lawyers who have tried to publicly explain what is going wrong with rape trials. He is so concerned about his inability to defend accused rapists that he now refuses to take on any case of this kind.
A week after the JIMS women came to speak, the UK Supreme Court (UKSC) made an astonishing ruling. The Daly and Keir case, as it is known, was about these two individuals, but much more than that, it was about how judges in Scotland had restricted evidence in rape trials. This had gone so far, the UKSC argued, that Scottish courts had been at risk of breaching fair trial rights since 2013.
This was the exact point that I had been writing about and the exact point that JIMS and other miscarriage of justice organisations were making. For me, for JIMS, and for many lawyers, including those from the Law Society of Scotland and the Faculty of Advocates who spoke at the Daly and Keir appeal, this was a landmark ruling. Scotland was no longer a country where you could say with any confidence that fair trials were taking place. This most fundamental of rights in a liberal democracy — indeed the most fundamental expectation of justice — had been undermined by the very people — judges — who one would hope are there to defend rather than undermine the justice system.
The muted reaction by Scottish politicians, the media, and the senior judicial figures was a shock to some, but it was one that I was expecting. It was something that I saw, and still see, as the biggest legal scandal in Scottish history. If you take the Guildford Four, the Birmingham Six and every other miscarriage of justice you can remember and multiply it many times, you get to the scale of what we are looking at. And yet there was largely nothing made of it by the authorities.
If anything, the reaction was to see the UKSC ruling as potentially harmful to rape victims who would be re-traumatised by both the news itself and the possibility that retrials may be necessary. Senior legal figures like the Lord Advocate Dorothy Bain discussed the “renewed anxiety, alarm and distress” of rape victims, while the Scottish Conservative spokesperson for victims, Sharon Dowey, described the outcome as creating “an extremely unsettling and distressing situation for victims of rape and sexual violence”.
These statements are illustrative and mirror the attitude that had developed among judges over many years, an attitude that I would argue demonstrates the shift we are seeing that is turning justice systems in many Western nations into victim justice systems. This is a system that takes a therapeutic and victim-centred approach to justice and does everything it can to protect victims, or vulnerable groups, and does so at the expense of fair trials and justice.
Before we look at the Scottish example, and at the reaction to JIMS coming to speak at my university, it is worth explaining that I have been reading and writing about what Campbell and Manning call a “victimhood culture” for 20 years. I could write a book on this issue, and I plan to.
Writing about the ‘rise of the victim’ took off in the 1990s. Here, various authors noted how this new symbolic figure of the victim had grown out of the 1970s and became a dominant influence in politics, law, and institutions. It may surprise people to note that even the term ‘victim of crime’ was rarely used until the 1960s. Before that, crime happened, but people were not defined as victims. Subsequently, as the American sociologist Joel Best notes, a victim industry developed, and across the board, campaigners began to promote their cause through the language of victimhood.
Additionally, victimhood developed from expressing a relationship to an event into an identity not only for individuals but also for entire groups of people.
Over time, and accelerating from the 1990s, politicians and wider institutions that lacked a clear sense of purpose and direction were drawn to the idea of protecting the vulnerable. Rather than representatives of active citizens, they increasingly became advocates for a more passive and disconnected electorate through the legalistic language of rights and protections. In the process, the very idea of what it was to be a person began to change, and it began to change most significantly in the heads of the new elites.
As well as the more pessimistic and cynical times, this trend for seeing humanity as both damaged and damaging was facilitated by activists and academics, most notably by feminists who, influenced by the times, shifted their focus from structural issues related to freedom and equality in the workplace, towards personal issues about harm and abuse. By 2011, Roger N. Lancaster described victim feminists as the most successful social movement of the modern era.
Helped by this era, when preventing harm rather than achieving good reflected the culture of limits described by Christopher Lasch and Frank Furedi, victim feminists became highly influential, most noticeably within Western criminal justice systems. As a result, speaking for and standing up for victims developed not only in policies and practices but also increasingly became a new type of morality. One could argue that the ‘victim’ has become the dominant moral category of contemporary public life and is a category that arguably lies behind the contemporary cancel culture.
Coming back to the issue of rape trials, for decades the shift towards a victim culture has led elites across the Western world to modify their practices. If protecting the vulnerable is the starting point, the adversarial justice system becomes a problem.
Initially, this was done through understandable concerns about the moralistic condemnation of women in court, where a woman’s entire sexual history was exposed as a way to discredit her. But over time, this legitimate concern morphed into a system where protecting the woman in court became a moral imperative.
The problem, of course, is that until a jury reaches a verdict, we do not know who the victim actually is. Is it the woman, or is it the man who is being mistakenly or falsely accused of a heinous crime? If the justice system, as it unquestionably is, starts to see the woman as a trauma victim rather than a complainer, the balance of justice is inevitably lost.
In politics and in law, as barrister Barbara Howson argues, the issue of violence against women and girls (VAWG) has created a ‘super victim’. Here we find that the moral weight of standing up for victims leads to claims, like that of Keir Starmer, who argued that it was “more sophisticated” to start from a position of assuming the complainer is telling the truth.
That the ex-director of public prosecutions seemingly disregards the fundamental need for impartiality is highly significant. His term “more sophisticated” is also telling and arguably reflects a move towards a #believe justice system. It is, of course, the enlightened and progressive elites who are “more sophisticated”, or to use the parlance of our time, are the people who are ‘aware’ and know what is good and true.
One additional point to note is that the issue of VAWG is not partisan. Across the board, politicians fall over themselves to talk about this endemic, epidemic, national, international, and ever-increasing problem. As a result, there is no space for dissent. Perhaps due to the influence of feminism, the moralistic quality associated with sex, the conservative love of ‘law and order’, and the right-wing concern about immigrants who threaten women and girls, there is no political party and almost no section of the media who see anything other than the victim. Alternatively, those people who can see what is happening, as Thomas Ross has noted, keep their heads down because they know that this is the issue that could destroy their career.
The lack of interest in the issue of a loss of fair trials and the mass miscarriage of justice taking place is partly due to ignorance. But ignorance is quickly overcome when it takes one’s fancy. Tragically, at the moment, there simply appears to be no appetite for understanding of what is taking place.
Around the issue of policing and race, many people talk of a ‘two-tier justice system’ and talk about this as a ‘culture war’. But one could equally argue that what is happening around the entire VAWG issue is both of these things, with bells on.
The culture war dimension of this can be seen in the way that the changes to the Scottish legal system have been justified.
Judges, for example, who systematically developed mechanisms to limit evidence in rape trials did so by arguing not only for the need to protect the woman from further trauma, but also by morally denouncing those dissenting judges who continued to call for evidence. More particularly, it was jurors, who were said to believe in rape myths, and to have a ‘19th-century’ way of thinking, that were seen as the real problem in rape trials. While dissenting judges were put in their place for their wrong-think, jurors needed to be kept at a distance from all sorts of evidence lest it ‘confuse’ them.
It was this belief in the backward nature of ordinary Scottish men and women that also led to the Scottish Government’s attempt to abolish jury trials in rape cases.
All this was done with the stated objective of increasing conviction rates in rape cases.
This political and judicial drive to increase the conviction rate in rape cases should set off myriad alarm bells.
Euan McIlvride, legal adviser at the Miscarriages of Justice Organisation (MOJO), argues:
My own take on it is a simple one. Where you create — and publicly declare — a political imperative to increase the rate of conviction for a certain type of crime, as an end in itself, and in pursuit of that, you bend the law to make it easier to convict and progressively harder to defend, the inevitable result will be — and is — miscarriages of justice.
This becomes all the more sinister when we consider that it is justified through the profoundly elitist and contemptuous attitude towards the Scottish public — the imagined deplorables. The threat this poses to the justice system but also to liberal and democratic values is significant.
These were some of the issues I was trying to discuss with my fourth-year criminology class. It was also why JIMS were brought in to speak. It was what they spoke about. Not their personal stories or even the idea of miscarriages of justice. The issue was a loss of fair trials.
Unfortunately, but perhaps not unexpectedly, a few of the JIMS women had found themselves battling with haters online. They had also made some volatile comments about rape victims. As a result, after advertising the fact that they had spoken at my university, a storm erupted online about the disgusting nature of JIMS, about me, and about my university. This was not merely a discussion about fair trials; it was an attack upon rape victims who were now being traumatised by these women and by me allowing them to speak.
Complaints flooded in. Graffiti on the wall appeared outside my office explaining what a sexist c*** I was. And then the media kicked into gear. Overnight, JIMS became a ‘rapist rights group’ filled with ‘rape apologists’, and my university felt the need to apologise to victims for any harm that had been caused.
A five-month investigation into the affair began, and it concluded that there was nothing wrong with the event. Perhaps helped by the fact that the Supreme Court ruling essentially backed what the JIMS speakers and I were saying, my university explained that the vast majority of complaints had come from outside the university and that academic freedom was important.
Consequently, I asked JIMS to come back in to speak again.
This time the reaction was worse. It was a different speaker this time, someone who, to my knowledge, had never said anything negative online. But that didn’t matter. Once again, JIMS were denounced as rape apologists and for traumatising rape victims. Green MSPs wrote to the university and minor celebrities, like Darren McGarvey, spoke about their outrage. McGarvey, a working-class addict made good who had received an honorary degree from my university, gave it back.
Darren McGarvey’s announcement is worth reading.
As well as raising some concerns about online posts about victims and the trauma this causes, he attacks JIMS for some of their views about misandry, #MeToo, and for claiming that boys are being taught to feel ashamed of their maleness. These ideas were “dog-whistles”, Darren explained, and were not about fair trials. Sounding somewhat born-again, he explains how he used to be a misogynist, but now he sees the error of his ways, and wants all men to have a look at themselves and to “develop the emotional and psychological resilience required to sit with the discomfort you’re so clearly hoping to avoid in this era of profound cultural change”.
As with much feminist writing, McGarvey sees himself as a culture warrior fighting the enormous tide of misogyny and hate. He sees himself as a brave soul going once more unto the breach, avoiding “easy answers” provided by algorithms. Unlike the algorithmically informed simple men, Darren is a man in Scotland who “won’t sit on the side-lines”. Though “speaking out comes with risks to me personally”, he has decided these are risks he is “willing to take”.
This fantasy world that Darren lives in is one of power and abuse where the enlightened few stand tall. The reality, of course, is that Darren is now celebrated for his ‘bravery’ for saying what every powerful institution, organisation and individual is already saying. In reality, he stands shoulder to shoulder with our new elites and their contemptuous attitudes about Scottish people and especially Scottish men — the potential jurors who must be kept far away from evidence in a court of law.
Ironically, McGarvey’s latest book is called . It opens with this:
Trauma has become one of the most dominant cultural issues of our time. It is everywhere, it seems – shaping our institutions, politics and even the language we use to understand ourselves and our relationships. It has redefined how we tell our stories, how we seek validation, and how we make sense of suffering. But has our current way of engaging with trauma genuinely served us? Or has it also, in many cases, become something else entirely — a currency, a performance, a mechanism that traps people within the very pain they seek to escape?
Darren asks whether ‘trauma’ has become packaged by advocates, by activism and the media, often benefiting institutions more than the people whose pain forms the basis of the story. Can we question the affirm-only approaches? Can we question the dominant orthodoxy and be brave enough to suggest that a trauma narrative may “occasionally become self-fulfilling, reinforcing identities rooted in pain”? Finally, he explains that the book asks whether our identity keeps us “locked in personas riddled with trauma, and whether over-identifying with victimhood is empowering or another form of psychological entrapment”.
Darren should join my fourth-year class because this is exactly what I try to examine. Sadly, I will no longer be examining any of this with the help of JIMS because they have now been banned from the institution, helped in part by the intervention of McGarvey himself.
JIMS don’t address the issue of trauma directly, but they are conscious of how it has been used within the justice system to encourage the very victim industry that McGarvey is talking about. Trauma is also the tool that has been used to pressurise my institution and to pressurise me. It is the basis of the complaints from outside the university and from some students and staff. Once trauma enters the picture, there is no reply. If someone says that JIMS makes them feel unsafe, they make them feel unsafe. If talking about subjects is triggering, then lecturers must look at themselves and change their ways.
Judges are now trained to be trauma-informed, thus creating another framework through which complainers in a court of law are further understood to be victims. Through this new ‘dominant cultural issue’, criminal justice staff are educated that virtually any behaviour can be explained by trauma: a person may remember vividly due to trauma. They may forget details due to trauma. They may report immediately due to trauma. They may delay for decades due to trauma. They may be emotional because of trauma. They may appear calm because of trauma.
Being ‘trauma-informed’ is the new enlightenment, a new type of morality, given to us by experts. It is also one of the justifications for getting rid of juries. Why? Because ordinary people can’t possibly have this expert sensibility. To really understand people, relationships, and ultimately rape victims, they need to have done their trauma training.
Out goes the respect for ‘common sense’ that is so central to law, and in comes yet another section of the professional classes to deconstruct and dismantle the democratic basis of jury trials.
In all this, perhaps the most depressing aspect is the way that the women of JIMS have been discussed and treated.
The gutter journalism is now so expected that it’s almost becoming background noise. The odd student who reports things said in class to the press is depressing, but it is now almost an expected occurrence. But the disingenuous attacks on JIMS are painful to watch.
Everyone with an ounce of common sense understands that the hatred expressed towards them is because they are going against the ‘super victim’ associated with the VAWG industry. If they were the accepted victims speaking out of turn online, there would be no pile-on, no media, no political outrage, nothing.
Criticism can be made about online comments, but let’s put this into perspective. These are ordinary women who have realised that the justice system is seriously flawed. They’re right. And they have energetically campaigned to try to raise the profile of this issue at a time when not only is nobody in authority doing anything about it, but also when questioning the dominant narrative around rape trials is a serious taboo. They believe that their men have been wrongly convicted. And here’s the rub. As the Supreme Court has said that there has been a systematic undermining of fair trials, they may very well be right. They may not be right in their individual cases, but on the general issue they are absolutely correct.
What they have done should be seen as a service to society and they should be congratulated for bringing this to our attention. But instead, they not only receive death and rape threats themselves, but are castigated and ridiculed by journalists, commentators, and the professional class who know little and care less about the experiences and ideas of these women.
Of course, this all comes at a time when there is much talk, even within the Scottish Parliament, about the significance of listening to ‘lived experience’. But once again, what they mean by lived experience is the lived experience of victims and vulnerable groups. Step outside this ethically acceptable framework, and your lived experience turns into ignorance, a lack of professionalism, or mere anecdotes that can be disregarded and ridiculed at will.
It is worth reiterating that the JIMS speakers do not talk about misandry, #MeToo, or anything else. They talk to the students about the work JIMS do and about fair trials.
“Don’t use these vile women”, I’m told. Get someone else in to talk to the students. Find professional people who don’t say offensive things online. But who else is there who will risk speaking on this subject? I guess I’m going to find out.
Cover image: The High Court of Justiciary at Saltmarket, Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom | CC BY-SA 3.0