Miriam Cates: Why a staggered age of consent is the wrong answer

Two celebrity sex scandals have dominated the front pages over the last fortnight. First came the conviction of disgraced comedian Russell Brand for a range of sexual offences, including rape. This was followed last week by the news that author David Walliams is the star hiding behind a court injunction following allegations of grooming young women over several years. Both men were accused of pursuing sexual relationships with girls as young as 16—something that is currently legal, provided it is consensual.

In the wake of these revelations—many of them deeply shocking—there have been growing calls to reform the law on sexual consent. Specifically, campaigners want to introduce a ‘staggered’ age of consent, making it illegal for adults over a certain age to have sex with 16- and 17-year-olds.

Like so many campaigns born out of public outrage over high-profile scandals, this change sounds sensible on a superficial level. Most people feel deeply uncomfortable with the prospect of men in their 30s, 40s, or even 50s sleeping with 16-year-old girls; certainly, most parents would do everything in their power to protect their daughters from such ‘relationships.’

Yet, as we ought to know by now, hard cases make bad law. Before rushing to legislate, we should be extremely careful about the unintended consequences of such a move.

Firstly, would a staggered age of consent have stopped Brand or Walliams? Most people following the Russell Brand trial will have been disgusted by the way he conducted himself sexually. Brand treated women as objects for his own gratification, acting selfishly, manipulatively, and with a callous disregard for his partners. However, most of the women he propositioned were over 18. Even if Brand had respected the law, a staggered age of consent would have saved very few women from his grasp. Yet, as his conviction proves, Brand did not respect the law, and he is in prison as a result.

As for David Walliams, one accuser alleges he suggested waiting until she turned 16 to have sex after she rebuffed his advances at 15, while another claims he began pursuing her sexually at 17 once she was safely past the age of consent. Yet it is far from clear how much harm would have been avoided had the legal threshold been 18 instead.

Secondly, how could such a law possibly be enforced? A staggered age of consent is significantly more complicated to police than a single, clear cut-off. Under the proposal put forward by campaign group Close the Consent Gap, 16- and 17-year-olds would be permitted to sleep with someone up to three years older than them, with all restrictions lifted at 18. In practice, this means a 17-year-old could legally date a 20-year-old, only for their relationship to become a criminal offence on the older partner’s 21st birthday.

When Layla Stone, founder of  ‘Close the Gap’ joined me on GB News on Sunday, she suggested that there should be a ‘carve-out’ for established relationships. But what counts as an ‘established relationship,’ and who decides if a particular partnership meets the criteria? How would a couple prove the date on which their relationship started—by handing over their private WhatsApp messages to the police?

This ambiguity would also open the door to vexatious complaints. Imagine a relationship between a 17-year-old sixth-former and a 21-year-old undergraduate who meet working Saturday shifts at a supermarket. They date for three years before suffering an acrimonious breakup. Under a staggered law, the younger partner could cynically weaponise the criminal justice system against an ex-lover for historical “” sex.

The primary reason to doubt that a staggered age of consent would work, however, is that our current, much simpler law is barely enforced as it is. In theory, sex with under-16s is illegal. Yet as the grooming gangs scandal tragically revealed, authorities routinely turned a blind eye, dismissing the abuse of 13- and 14-year-old girls by older men as ‘consensual’ or a ‘lifestyle choice.’

Countless opportunities to prosecute abusers were missed because social workers, health professionals, and police failed to treat underage sex as a crime. Even where prosecutions are sought, Crown Prosecution Service guidance advises against criminal proceeding in the case of 14- and 15- year olds having sex with other teenagers—meaning that, in effect, the de facto age of consent in Britain is just 13 – the age of statutory rape. There is little point inventing complex new laws to protect 17-year-olds from a small number of badly behaved celebrities when the state refuses to enforce existing laws protecting 13-year-olds from organised crime gangs operating all over the country.

Thirdly, conservatives should reject the ideology behind this campaign. Advocacy for a staggered age of consent is rooted in the ‘progressive,’ neo-Marxist worldview that all human interactions are defined by power, neatly divided into oppressors and victims. Under this framing, it is assumed that an age gap automatically means that there is a power imbalance in the relationship in favour of the older (male) partner, and that the state must intervene to flatten or prevent that imbalance. In the same way, progressives assume white people always hold unfair power over black people, employers over employees, men over women, straight people over gay people and so on.

This ideology is plainly untrue. Human relationships are complex and multifaceted with unique interpersonal dynamics. While men certainly hold a physical strength advantage over women, the vast majority of sexual and romantic relationships are not defined by brute force. In a free society where women choose whom they date and marry, females wield immense sexual power; they are the gatekeepers of sex. Just as older men are attracted to young women for obvious evolutionary reasons, young women are often drawn to older, established, high-status men. Many young women are acutely aware of their sexual power and use it to attract partners, just as men rely on stature and achievement. Furthermore, there is no guarantee that a 17-year-old boy will treat a teenage girl with any more kindness, respect, or maturity than a 25-year-old man.

Power dynamics and tension are an inherent part of human sexuality. A mutually rewarding relationship between a younger woman and an older man – or vice versa – is not automatically exploitative. If we accept that a person possesses the capacity to consent to sex, then we must accept that they have the capacity to consent to sex with someone regardless of their age. Either an individual has agency, or they do not.

Yet given that we classify anyone under 18 as a child, and have recently raised the legal age of marriage to 18, there is a coherent argument for increasing the age of consent from 16 to 18 to match. That is a debate worth having. However, any changes to the age of consent should be based on an understanding of the age at which an average young person achieves the maturity to make an wise decision, rather than a desire for the state to police age gap relationships based on assumed power imbalances.

Ultimately, this debate exposes the inadequacy of “” as our sole framework for sexual ethics. What shocks us about Brand and Walliams is not that they crossed a technical legal boundary, but that they treated women so callously. Theirs was not primarily a legal failure, but a moral one—compounded by the moral cowardice of the enablers around them, such as their employers, colleagues and employees – including the driver who took Brand’s distressed victim home while turning a blind eye because the encounters were ostensibly ‘consensual.’

We cannot, and should not, legislate against bad character. The criminal law cannot protect young people from heartbreak, regret, or cruel partners any more than it can stop us from falling out with friends or being mistreated by a boss. Protecting young people, teaching them how to identify bad actors, and challenging predatory men is the duty of parents, families, colleagues and communities—not a job we can outsource to the statute book.

Original source Miriam Cates: Why a staggered age of consent is the wrong answer

Back to home