Observations of an Expat: Burham, Brexit and Democratic Accountability

This week’s EU-UK summit was opportunity to repair the damage caused by Brexit. Real progress was made. But there is a danger that closer cooperation will come at the expense of democratic accountability.

After years of unnecessary friction, Britain and the European Union appear ready to make substantial progress towards a more constructive relationship. Agreements on food standards, carbon emissions, defence cooperation and youth mobility will bring tangible benefits to both sides.

For those of us who believe that Britain’s future lies in closer cooperation with our European neighbours, this is encouraging. Brexit has demonstrated that geographical proximity, shared economic interests and common security concerns cannot simply be wished away by political declarations of independence.

Yet there is an important constitutional issue which deserves considerably more attention than it has received in the political debate. As Britain moves towards closer alignment with European regulations, how do we ensure that our own Parliament retains meaningful democratic control over the laws which govern us?

This is not an argument against closer cooperation. It is an argument for ensuring that such cooperation rests on sound democratic foundations.

The issue is known as dynamic alignment. In simple terms, it means that Britain agrees to keep its legislation aligned with EU rules in particular areas, including changes which the EU may introduce in the future.

Take the proposed agreement on food and agricultural standards. It could remove many of the cumbersome checks and certificates which currently make trade between Britain and the EU more expensive and complicated. British farmers and food producers would benefit from easier access to European markets. Consumers and businesses could also gain.

But there is a price attached. To enjoy these advantages, Britain would have to follow relevant changes to EU legislation. We could be consulted and have opportunities to influence discussions, but we would no longer have the voting rights enjoyed by EU member states in the institutions which make those laws.

In other words, we could find ourselves implementing legislation over which our elected representatives had little direct influence.

This is not a theoretical concern. The House of Lords European Affairs Committee has just published a substantial report, Dynamic Alignment: A Fundamental Change, which examines precisely these implications. Its conclusions deserve serious attention.

The committee warns that dynamic alignment will require a fundamental change in the way the British Government and Parliament handle European legislation. It further argues that existing parliamentary scrutiny arrangements are inadequate for the task ahead.

The problem is one of scale as well as principle. Hundreds of pieces of European legislation could potentially fall within the scope of the new arrangements. Parliament will need appropriate procedures, institutional arrangements and resources if it is to scrutinise them properly.

The Government is proposing a European Partnership Bill to provide the domestic legislative machinery for implementing the new arrangements. But passing a Bill is not the same thing as resolving the democratic question. In fact, it could create a new problem.

Suppose the European Union introduces a new regulation affecting British agricultural producers. Our Government may consider it sensible to adopt the change because the commercial benefits of maintaining alignment outweigh the disadvantages. But what if Parliament disagrees? What if the new regulation imposes disproportionate costs on British businesses, or conflicts with a policy which MPs believe should be determined domestically?

If we have already entered into a binding international agreement requiring alignment, the Government’s room for manoeuvre may be severely restricted. Refusing to follow the agreed rules could put the wider agreement, and the benefits it provides, at risk.

Of course, Britain would remain a sovereign state in the formal sense. The EU cannot simply legislate directly for the UK as though we were still members. But sovereignty is not merely the theoretical ability to say no. It is also the practical ability of elected representatives to influence the decisions which affect their constituents.

There is a further difficulty. Britain may be able to participate in discussions and attempt to influence the development of European legislation. This is sometimes described as ‘decision-shaping’. But it is not decision-making. We would have no vote in the European Parliament or Council of Ministers.

We would therefore be accepting a degree of regulatory dependence without enjoying the democratic representation which accompanies EU membership.

I believe we should welcome the principle of dynamic alignment where it delivers clear economic and social benefits. It would be perverse to reject closer cooperation simply because it requires us to accept common standards. Many of the regulations concerned protect consumers, workers, the environment and public health. There is no virtue in maintaining different rules merely to demonstrate that we can. But we must also insist on proper democratic safeguards.

First, Parliament needs a properly resourced European Affairs Committee, or equivalent scrutiny arrangements, capable of examining relevant European legislation as it develops. Ministers should be required to explain which changes the Government proposes to accept and why.

Second, Parliament must have an effective opportunity to debate significant changes before the Government commits Britain to them. There should be a clear procedure for raising objections where a proposed regulation would have substantial consequences for British interests.

Third, the Government must be transparent about the financial contributions involved in participation in European programmes and regulatory arrangements. The public is entitled to know what it is paying for and what benefits it receives.

Fourth, the devolved administrations must be properly involved. Decisions concerning agriculture, environmental standards and other devolved responsibilities cannot sensibly be treated as matters for Westminster alone.

These are the minimum requirements of a healthy parliamentary democracy.

The House of Commons Foreign Affairs Committee has also highlighted the need for stronger scrutiny arrangements and has examined whether mechanisms allowing Parliament to object to particular developments in EU law could be introduced.

There is a broader political irony here. One of the principal arguments advanced by Brexit supporters was that leaving the European Union would restore democratic control over British legislation. Yet the economic consequences of leaving have encouraged successive governments to seek arrangements which bring us back into closer regulatory alignment.

The challenge is to ensure that we do not replace one perceived democratic deficit with another.

Ultimately, this debate raises the more fundamental question about Britain’s long-term relationship with Europe. The Burnham Government has ruled out rejoining the single market or customs union during this Parliament, but the political debate about our future relationship is unlikely to end there. There is every possibility that a return to the EU will be on the ballot at the next general election.

But democratic accountability must accompany every step towards closer integration. Cooperation should strengthen democracy, not diminish it.

The Brussels summit should therefore be judged not simply by the number of agreements signed or the economic benefits promised. It should also be judged by whether the Government has recognised its responsibility to keep Parliament fully informed and involved.

The real test of a successful European partnership is not how many regulations Britain agrees to follow. It is whether the British people, through their elected representatives, retain a meaningful voice in the decisions which shape their lives.

* Tom Arms is foreign editor of Liberal Democrat Voice. He also contributes to “The New World” magazine and lectures on world affairs. He is the author of “America Made in Britain,” two editions of “The Encyclopaedia of the Cold War” and “The Falklands Crisis.”

Original source Observations of an Expat: Burham, Brexit and Democratic Accountability

Back to home