
Are you feeling rich yet?
According to the ONS, the UK economy grew by 0.7 per cent in the third quarter of this year — that is, in July, August and September.
It’s not exactly a boom, but it’s better than 0.3 per cent for Canada, 0.2 per cent for Germany, 0.1 per cent for Japan, 0.0 per cent for Italy and a pitiful minus 0.1 per cent for France. In the G7, only the Americans, on 0.8 per cent , outgrew us.
Our third quarter growth also breaks an established pattern in which the British economy starts off well in the first half of the year and then loses steam after the summer. But not this year, it would seem. Indeed, we might overtake the Germans to become the second fastest growing G7 economy for the whole of 2026.
A caveat, though: it might not last. For instance, conflict in the Gulf and Red Sea regions threatens further disruption to fossil fuel supplies — and thus further inflation. We’d also be foolish to take the money markets for granted.
For the moment, though, the bond vigilantes are focused on France. Not only does the bloated French state make ours look skinny, there’s also a major political upheaval on the cards as Marine Le Pen hardens her lead in the opinion polls. So, if only by comparison, things aren’t looking too bad for Britain.
What, then, does that mean for Conservative economic policy?
Let’s face it, opposing Labour when Rachel Reeves was Chancellor wasn’t the most stretching task. But her replacement, John Healey, will be a tougher nut to crack. Yes, there wasn’t much to his nothing-burger budget, but it satisfied the markets and, judging by recent polls, a winning share of voters too. And now he’s got an encouraging set of GDP figures to wave about.
So how should Andrew Griffith, the Shadow Chancellor, respond?
I’d start by understanding the essential character of Labour’s economic policy. Forget Burnham’s blather about reversing 40 years of neoliberalism, just look at what the government is actually doing. One could call it ‘big state fiscal conservatism’ — i.e. a combination of stimulus through state spending and deficit reduction through tax rises.
If you’re not feeling rich yet then that might be because you work in the private sector — where workers have seen their pay increases outstripped as a result of the government’s obedience to the unions. Clearly those fattened public sector pay packets have helped fuel growth and offset the deadening impact of Rachel Reeves’ tax increases. At the same time, it’s because of that money-grabbing that the IMF has praised the UK as the only G7 country with a serious deficit reduction plan.
If ‘big state fiscal conservatism’ sounds like a contradiction in terms, then that’s because it is. It certainly isn’t sustainable. John Healey has already lowered Rachel Reeves’ fiscal headroom — a dangerous policy in a bumpy world. There’s also a financial and political limit to how far Labour can pump up public sector wages. Then there’s the fact that many of the announced tax increases — for instance, the expansion of the Mansion Tax — aren’t due to hit until 2028 and beyond. The back-loading of fiscal pain also applies to spending restraint. I was taken by what Paul Johnson, former director of the IFS, said about the extent of the cuts implied by the government’s budgetary plans: “pull the other one it’s got bells on”.
The grumbling against the Milburn Review from Labour backbenchers is an early warning of the trouble that Healey and Burnham will face if they try to tame the welfare budget. Meanwhile the delay to the Comprehensive Spending Review is clear sign that the Prime Minister has chosen to put off the difficult decisions rather than use his political capital to get the job done in good time.
But here’s the danger for the Conservative leadership: while Kemi and Co can justifiably taunt ministers with charges of kicking the can down the road, that doesn’t add up to a fully-developed economic philosophy. The same can be said about the tax cuts unveiled at this year’s and (last year’s) party conference — which were essentially political, not economic. As for statements of timeless principle like , they too are insufficient. What we need are radical policy responses commensurate with the biggest economic challenges of our time.
What are these challenges? Well, we can find a good few of them if we delve deeper into the latest growth figures.
For one thing, it’s worth noting that the growth rate for GDP per capita was the same as the headline growth rate i.e. 0.7 per cent. In other words, we didn’t increase the size of the economy merely by adding people. In fact, legal immigration to the UK is falling fast. It’s almost as if infinity migrants is not a precondition for growth. So the renewal of Conservative economic policy could start with a purge of demonstrably false assumptions. Quite clearly, the era of mass immigration has not resulted in healthier economies or happier societies across the West — so let’s drop the pretence.
Another interesting feature of the UK’s third quarter growth is how uneven it is. Just look at the construction sector, which shrank by 0.7 per cent. The obvious point to make here is about the failure of the Labour housing and planning policy — as famously predicted by Badenoch before she became leader.
But dare we tackle some of the trickier implications?
For instance, it would appear that spamming apartment blocks across our towns and cities is no more a prerequisite for overall GDP growth than unrestricted migration. One night also note that despite the shortfall in new supply, UK property prices are barely rising — and actually falling in London. It’s almost as if the standard narrative woven around house building and the economy is fundamentally wrong. Indeed, I’d go so far as to venture that basing the push for more development on runaway house price inflation (maintained by demand subsidies) has actively harmed the British economy.
But before the red mist descends, let me move on to another poorly performing part of the economy: retail and hospitality. With businesses closing and jobs being lost, it would be easy — and correct — to blame Labour policy. But the underlying problems go much deeper. To save our town centres, we need a fundamental rethink on how to balance the burden of taxation across (a) shops and other high street businesses, (b) their out-of-town and online equivalents, and (c) the property industry. For instance, would the next Conservative government have the guts to replace business rates with a land value tax paid by commercial landlords? That could be a game-changer, but some of the most determined lobbyists in British politics wouldn’t like it.
And now for the most significant contributor to UK economic growth: investment in artificial intelligence. According to an assessment by Bloomberg Economics, AI is already responsible for something like a quarter of UK GDP growth.
Though we’re a long way behind the Americans and the Chinese, Britain can reasonably boast third place in the global AI league table. On some measures we’re now attracting more AI investment than the rest of Europe combined. There are several components to this comparative success. Our world leading universities are important as is our finance sector, but our trump card is that we’re not subject to the EU’s doomed attempt to regulate its way to the future. In particular, we’re free from the EU AI Act — a bureaucratic nightmare that is the modern-day equivalent to the 1865 Red Flag Act (which required someone with a red flag to walk ahead of any self-propelled road vehicle).
For American tech companies seeking to invest abroad, the fact that the UK market lies outside the reach of the EU AI Act is a major plus point. And given the potential of this technology, that advantage could prove as important to us today as North Sea oil was in 1970s — quite possibly more so. And yet, in his headlong pursuit of regulatory alignment with the EU, Andy Burnham is on the brink of throwing it away.
It’s an issue on which Kemi Badenoch should be ready to go to war — just as William Hague went all out to save the pound. Of course, it can be argued that this battle diverted Hague from the task of winning a general election. But equally, it can be argued that he got his priorities right.
Today, because we stayed out of the single currency and then left the EU altogether, we have an opportunity to develop a visionary economic policy for Britain as a fully sovereign state. It is the great unfinished work of Brexit — so let’s complete it.