
Ryan Shorthouse is the Executive Chair of Bright Blue
The UK’s Not in Education, Employment or Training (NEET) rate for 16-24-year-olds is now one of the worst in Europe, second only to Romania. Most of this rise is down to an increase in economic inactivity among those aged under 25, with two-thirds of new benefit claims for 16-25-year-olds being driven by anxiety, depression, ADHD or autism.
There has been a genuine rise in internalising mental disorders across the Western world, especially among young adults, as Professor Jonathan Haidt demonstrates in his most recent book The anxious generation. But, as the Chair of the DWP Labour Market Advisory Board, Professor Paul Gregg, explains, the UK is largely unique in Europe in experiencing a significant rise in youth economic inactivity associated with these mental disorders.
The recent government-commissioned Fonagy Review also argued that there has been a rise in diagnosis of autism and ADHD, but not necessarily a rise in prevalence.
Blame is often pinned on the pandemic. But I’m afraid the Tories should also accept their share of it. Universal Credit (UC) is often heralded as a success of the 2010s — since, by the end of that decade, the employment rate reached historic highs, and the NEET rate fell to a historic low. Those successes should in fact be attributed to other policies.
Beset by delays, UC was only available nationwide to new claimants from December 2018, with existing claimants migrated onto it only from 2019. Prior to this, it was being piloted with a focus on claimants with relatively straightforward claims. It wasn’t until February 2021 that a majority of all benefit claimants were on UC.
UC introduced – mainly from the late 2018 nationwide rollout – the unconditional health element, a generous supplement to the Standard Allowance where claimants are classified as having Limited Capability for Work and Work-Related Activity (LCWRA), with no conditions on claimants to prepare, plan or search for work.
Equally, though the Conservative-led Government in 2013 introduced Personal Independence Payment (PIP) — the universal benefit for working-aged adults to help with extra disability-related living costs — it wasn’t until August 2018 that it had taken over its predecessor, the Disability Living Allowance (DLA), as the main disability benefit for the majority of claimants.
The spike in disability-related claims seems to have predated the pandemic, with the acceleration pronounced from 2019-2020 onward. There was a 46 per cent growth in numbers receiving incapacity or disability benefits between 2019-20 and 2023-24, the period in which UC and PIP started to be claimed by a majority of claimants.
The rise in NEETs has also happened during a period when the cost of hiring young people has augmented because of significant increases in the wage floor and payroll taxes. Fraser Nelson has estimated that over half of the increase in higher employment costs since 2011-2012 occurred during the last three years alone.
Bluntly, if we are to reduce the NEET rate, we need to make it harder for young adults to claim disability-related benefits and easier for employers to hire young adults. In other words, to fix the problem, we need a significant change in incentives, not a significant increase in public investment. Lamentably, the Milburn Review has chosen the latter approach.
The Milburn Review admits that “there is no shortage of schemes, pilots and initiatives for young people”, but still advocates for more taxpayer investment in youth employment policies that will eventually total £5.8 billion per year. At a time when we desperately need to reduce public expenditure, especially so that younger taxpayers are not ladened with paying off our historically unpreceded public debt, this upfront investment for highly speculative net fiscal savings that only accrue in 2036-2037 is, I am afraid, totally unnecessary and irresponsible.
After a decade, the Milburn Review predicts £3.6 billion per annum in savings from reduced welfare claims and £2.4 billion per annum in increased revenue savings from its proposed reforms. Hokum. Benefit claims do derive from predictable events, but also unpredictable events: suddenly losing a job or becoming ill, no matter what employment schemes are in place. The number of claimants is hard to accurately predict for the next year, let alone for the next decade.
It will be inefficient — with costs and timescale hard to predict — to create a completely new benefits system for those aged under 25, especially when the changes seem cosmetic. The new Youth Allowance, proposed by the Milburn Review, will be the same as the under 25s Standard Allowance in UC.
There will also still be an Additional Costs Allowance that replaces PIP, but the amounts available are not specified. The health element of UC is essentially being localised in a new Local Health and Disability Fund. Good luck accurately forecasting the number of claimants and the value of awards accurately with all this.
On tax receipts from employment too, this is very dependent on unknown endogenous and exogenous factors, including different governments setting tax rates and wage floors.
So, the Treasury, quite rightly, is very sceptical of —and usually rejects —sizeable invest-now-save-later policies, considering the considerable limitations with lots of modelling, unless there is a particularly robust evidence base or political pressure from above is applied. Since both borrowing costs and the size of net public sector debt are frighteningly high at the moment, I’d be siding with traditional Treasury thinking if I was the PM.
Not that Alan Milburn, whose pro-competition reforms as Health Secretary in the 2000s were evidentially the best reforms to our NHS ever seen, has got everything wrong. Unsurprisingly, he has done a thorough and thoughtful job of assessing and proposing how different parts of the state can work better for young adults. Some proposed changes are clever and will make a real difference, such as an increase in the early years pupil premium and same-day community mental health services for young people.
But, deep down, this is a very Blairite plan: new statutory tests, targets and guarantees. More joined-up government. Essentially, bigger and bossier government. Overall, this was a missed opportunity to be bolder and give more young people today clearer pathways to purposefulness and prosperity.
The amount of UC those aged under 25 can receive relative to older people could have been widened, justified by parents’ responsibility to support their children at this age. Eligibility for both the health element of UC and PIP could have been tightened.
Those with mild-to-moderate mental health problems or neurodivergence should not be entitled to claim any state benefit, including statutory sick pay, for that condition alone, unless in extreme circumstances. Some of the savings could instead be directed to the proliferation of same-day community mental health services for all young people, allowing them to get a diagnosis, advice, treatment or medication promptly, instead of waiting weeks, sometimes months, to get a GP appointment and referral.
The most important tax cut for the economy right now is that on effort and enterprise. The Milburn Review should have proposed faster and more expansive cuts to Employers’ National Insurance for those aged under 25, justified by good evidence from Europe that this increases total youth employment.
The fact is that taking on a young hire is more of a cost and risk to an employer than recruiting an experienced one. Businesses need stronger incentives to recruit them. The Milburn Review should have also proposed that the Labour Government drops its pledge to harmonise the minimum wage between under-21s and those aged above completely.
Frankly, as well as changes to incentives, we also need a change in culture. When you have left school, getting a job, training or support is a privileged opportunity you should work for. They should not be an automatic legal right given to you, as the Milburn Review proposes — not just for moral reasons, but because of unforeseen legal consequences too.