Sam Collins: Three lessons from New Zealand for the British right

Sam Collins, is former National Party Candidate and head of Head of Public Affairs at Popular Conservatism 

Chris Hipkins, New Zealand Labour leader, put it best after the preliminary results came in – “the people have spoken, but we’re not sure what they’ve said yet”. The New Zealand General Election, held on November 7th, is on a knife edge, with the final result (and the identity of the next Prime Minister) waiting for the counting of hundreds of thousands of ‘special votes’ (cast outside the voter’s constituency, usually from overseas). But regardless of the final result, the election campaign and its aftermath offer some useful lessons for the British right.

The first is the danger of announcing in advance that you won’t work with another party, particularly when that decision is driven by personal dislike or animosity.

As happened with National in 2017 (where their longstanding issues with New Zealand First leader Winston Peters led them to rule him out, only for Peters to hold the balance of power and put Jacinda Ardern into power), doing so can leave a party leader in an awkward position if the seat numbers don’t stack up as they would like. Explicitly ruling out a party only to be forced by the election result to reverse that position makes a leader look weak and undermines their authority. Standing by that position – as National should do regarding the big state, big tax Opportunity Party who National Leader Chris Luxon ruled out at the beginning of the campaign – means taking responsibility for a left wing government. A leader should be very sure that another party is unable to fit within their government ideology before ruling them out.

New Zealand has a Mixed Member Proportional (MMP) electoral system, but this lesson is arguably even more important in the British context. Under a fractured First Past the Post (FPTP) system, election results are almost impossible to predict. A relatively small number of voters moving one way or the other can have an outsized impact on the outcome. And if voters elect a Parliament without a Conservative majority, they will not look kindly on being forced back to the polls simply because politicians with clearly aligned interests cannot play nicely together.

All right-wing parties therefore should, at the very least, stop unnecessarily antagonising one another. Current polling suggests that if the Conservatives are to form a government and make Kemi Badenoch Prime Minister, they will need the acquiescence of Reform. While we all (myself included!) had a wonderful chuckle at the Birmingham ‘tapestry’ and the repeated references to a certain diminutive former Shadow Justice Secretary, it would be considerably less amusing if this poisoned the relationship between the Conservatives and Reform to the point where cooperation to keep the left out became impossible. The same is true of the stupidly antagonistic approach of Reform spokespeople and members to Conservatives. But, in our system, this inter-party bombast could easily lead to a socialist rainbow coalition, or another five years of Labour.

The second lesson, although frankly one we should have learned ourselves by now, is that splitting the vote has consequences for the overall balance of power between left and right. Although the New Zealand system positively encourages tactical voting, there are still around five constituencies (out of 71) where the combined vote for ACT and NZ First (both parties of the right) exceeded the margin between National and the winning Labour candidate. Alongside these, there are three other constituencies where National leads but could lose to Labour once the special votes are counted. The impact of vote splitting could therefore be the difference between a right-wing landslide and a left-wing coalition. Under FPTP, this fracturing of the right giving the left a free pass could have much greater impact.

It is almost impossible not to have noticed the impact of vote splitting on the overall performance of the right in Britain already. Recent council by-elections in Dudley, Dover and Hyndburn, among others, are showing a worrying trend: collectively, the right-wing vote is overwhelmingly popular (reaching up to two-thirds of the total), but the divisions mean a single left-wing candidate wins with a plurality. Those celebrating narrow Conservative or Reform defeats and the election of a left-wing candidate need to reconsider their priorities, particularly if they genuinely believe, as most on the right publicly claim, that a government of the left would have harmful consequences for the country and its citizens.

The final lesson is that ‘the vision thing’ matters more than ever. Across the Western world, politics has become increasingly focused on anger and negativity, on both sides of the spectrum. The success of The Opportunity Party in New Zealand, which received 6% of the vote and looks set to become the first genuinely outsider party to enter Parliament since Social Credit in the 1960s, is instructive. National and the other parties of the right campaigned hard on the risks posed by the left. And, for what it’s worth, those risks are very real: billions in additional spending, nine new taxes, including a land tax and a wealth tax, and a renewed commitment to net zero are all policies that prospective left-wing coalition partners have advocated.

But, as it turned out, this wasn’t enough for large numbers of voters, particularly younger Kiwis. They liked the happy-go-lucky optimism of Opportunity and demanded more from National and the other parties of the right than dry economics and warnings about the threat from the left.

We see the same in Britain. Voters today have lived through the financial crisis, Covid, two economically significant, if geographically distant, wars, and an economic and social contract that has never had the space to fully recover from any of them. In Britain, as with MAGA in America, we may be seeing a shift away from the politics of anger and towards a demand for thought-through, practical solutions.

On paper, this should be an opportunity for the Conservatives. Reform’s gradual shift from a party of happy warriors taking on the establishment to one of angry quasi-revolutionaries has coincided with a gradual decline in its polling numbers. And while Andy Burnham’s cheerful, Manchester-centred approach seems to have found favour with the public, it remains to be seen whether he can turn the ‘vibes’ into a credible and deliverable positive policy platform. Voters want to be able to imagine a better future – and also to understand how we can get there.

Kemi seems to have done well in developing a vision, but perhaps the biggest lesson from New Zealand is that leaders looking to galvanise the nation need to dial up the positivity. Practical policies are crucial, but a deeper explanation of why those policies are both needed and beneficial also needs to be given. Welfare reform and economic freedom are vital policies for the country’s future, but they are about far more than numbers on a spreadsheet.

All politics is, at its heart, about real people. We need to give people hope, backed by credible policies, not just numbers or empty vibes. And that is an opportunity, once taken by Margaret Thatcher, just waiting to be seized by Kemi Badenoch.

Original source Sam Collins: Three lessons from New Zealand for the British right

Back to home