Special needs overhaul in England could bring in new avenues for extra support

Families of children with special needs may get new avenues to appeal for extra support at school, under major concessions being considered for the government's overhaul of special needs education in England.

The move comes as the government's reforms are being repeatedly criticised by campaigners and parents' groups for watering down legal protections allowing families to appeal through a high court tribunal for support.

Lucy Powell, the education secretary, has told MPs who raised the issue to "wait and see", hinting that changes to the appeals process were "a key part of what we are looking at to make sure there are those mechanisms in place".

Stakeholders involved in the discussions told the Guardian that two independent appeal routes were under consideration, allowing families a forum to complain if they are dissatisfied with the provision offered by their child's school.

The government's white paper on special education needs and disability (Send) provision and funding, published in February, replaces the widespread use of agreements known as education, health and care plans (EHCPs) with new tiers of support to be managed by schools, known as individual support plans (ISPs).

But while parents can currently appeal to an independent first-tier Send tribunal to resolve disputes over EHCPs, the government's reforms would restrict that route and instead see complaints over ISPs dealt with by each child's school – which special needs groups quickly criticised as inadequate.

In response, policymakers began considering new appeal routes after the white paper was published under Bridget Phillipson as education secretary.

One route would allow parents to appeal to the local government and social care ombudsman, which already investigates complaints made against local authorities over Send provision and school transport.

An alternative route could be parents appealing to an independent review panel, modelled on the panels that hear appeals against school exclusions. These panels have the power to overturn exclusion decisions, and are appointed by local authorities with a clerk and up to five experts who have no direct connection to the school involved.

Jane Harris, the chief executive of Speech and Language UK, a charity, said: "Children with speech and language challenges and their families have been let down for far too long.

"So any new appeals system must give parents a genuinely independent, swift and effective way to challenge decisions and secure the education and therapy their children need to thrive.

"Schools and nurseries cannot be expected to mark their own homework, however. Leaving them with the final say would not only undermine parents' confidence in the system but also risk damaging relationships between families and the very people responsible for supporting their children every day.

"Whatever body hears appeals, the people hearing them must be independent and have the right expertise, and their decisions must be legally meaningful and lead to timely action. Anything else leaves children at risk."

Madeleine Cassidy, the chief executive of Ipsea, a charity that helps families navigate the special needs system, said it was "encouraging" that the government was considering alternatives.

Cassidy said: "The proposal to weaken the powers of the Send tribunal and reduce families' opportunities to challenge decisions has been a significant source of concern for parents and carers of children and young people with Send.

"Ipsea has long called for the local government and social care ombudsman's remit to be extended to schools so that complaints about the support children with Send receive can be independently investigated.

"However, stronger complaints mechanisms must not come at the expense of robust, enforceable legal rights."

A Department for Education spokesperson said: "We know parents want reassurance their child will get the support they need, and that they have clear routes to resolution if things do go wrong.

"We are considering all the input we have received from our engagement events and consultation and it would not be right to get ahead of that.

"In the meantime, we're investing in schools to improve inclusion and build a system where every child gets the right support, in their local area, without a fight."

Powell was questioned this month by parliament's education select committee, with Mark Sewards, the Labour MP for Leeds South West and Morley, telling her that parents were concerned about losing rights of appeal.

Powell replied: "This is a complex area. We are absolutely determined in these closing stages to get that detail right so families and parents do feel, yes, there's a level playing field, but also there's accountability in the system."

The government's bill and its response to its consultation on the Send white paper is not expected to be ready until early next year.

But the latest official statistics underline the importance of the appeals processes and the urgent need for reform.

In October, the government revealed that the average waiting time for a final oral hearing at the Send tribunal is longer than 18 months, meaning that an appeal lodged now would wait until May 2028 to be heard.

The tribunal is also receiving record numbers of appeals, with 8,800 lodged with the high court in the three months to June alone. The tribunal's backlog rose to 18,000 appeals, a 31% increase since 2025.

Original source Special needs overhaul in England could bring in new avenues for extra support

Back to home